How Restaurant Wine Buyers Make Their Selections (or Should)

How Restaurant Wine BuyersI was a restaurant wine buyer for years before focusing exclusively on wine education. I also discuss the struggles and success of many of my friends who work in that capacity and to those who sell wholesale to them. From all of this I thought I had seen it all. That was until I was invited to the wine team’s monthly tasting at Hakkasan Restaurant in San Francisco recently.

Some restaurant wine buyers taste sample wines with the vendors for hours every day. Others limit it to 1-2 days per week. Some require appointments and some allow or even encourage drop-ins. Some insist on unopened bottles being left for them to taste without the vendor being present, whenever they get to it. I even witnessed a restaurant manager who required her handful of vendors to show up every Monday morning and stand in line at the wine room door to prepare their own wine orders.

I usually limited wine vendor appointments to 1-2 days a week for about 2 hours each day. Most of my tastings were by appointment with the vendor. I would on occasion accept a drop-in tasting and always accepted drop-off bottles unopened or opened at an earlier appointment. If I was considering a wine for a “by the glass” spot, I would usually ask to take the rest of the bottle home so I could sample how it evolved over a few days. If it deteriorated too quickly it might work on the bottle list but not by the glass. Occasionally I would try the wine with an item from the food menu for pairing. Sometimes I would seek staff input simply to give them a sense of ownership, buy-in, being heard, etc.. Mostly, I operated as a one man buying center, though. A fair amount of my new selections also came from sampling wines at trade tastings.

How Restaurant Wine Buyers 2What I experienced at Hakkasan was far better than anything I have done as far as keeping the staff involved, encouraging the vendors to bring the most appropriate wines and ensure that there are great wines and great food pairings for the guests. I do not know how they compared to my body of work as far as cost control, sales, turning over inventory, keeping items in stock and maintaining the overall balance of the entire wine list. My guess is that they are quite on top of all of it.

Two of my graduates, Ronald Plunkett and Cassandra Brown, are on the team of 5 sommeliers at Hakkasan. They were both there when I was invited along with Senior Sommelier, Cara Patricia and wine team members Erica Woski and Shane McDermott.The team does a lunch time tasting once a month inviting a different person in the wine world outside of their restaurant to join them each month. First we all tasted some new wines that were dropped off by vendors to see if they were good enough on their own to warrant trying them with food. A few were eliminated at this round by group decision. Next we tasted 6 wines with 10 menu items. Some of the wines were from the previous round and not currently on the wine list. Others were already on the wine list. Each person rated the pairing of every wine with every dish. Yikes, that’s 60 combinations! In the end, a few wines got added to the list and some that were already on were about to see a spike in sales. Kudos to the wine team and the upper management for their very high standards.

How Restaurant Wine Buyers 3

Check out Catherine Fallis’ July 19 blog “Selling Wine to Sommeliers” and any wine buyer, restaurant manager or wholesaler in California  should be intimately familiar with the Tied House and Dram Shop Laws.

What is your process for sampling new wines?
Do you taste with the vendors or away from their influence?
Are new wines selected by committee or one person?

Sign up for our weekly blogs.  See our upcoming full program and single course schedule. Private, customized corporate training is also available.

Also in Blog

Best Winery Tours and Tasting in California!

Best Winery Tours and Tasting in California! I am regularly asked what wineries are the best to visit in California. With over 3,800 wineries in the state and American Viticultural Areas (AVAs) in 43 of the state’s 58 counties it can be hard to choose. Below are my picks for Napa and Sonoma with other regions to be discussed in future weeks.

Continue Reading

An Interview with Karen MacNeil
An Interview with Karen MacNeil

We recently caught up with Karen MacNeil, author of the best -selling book The Wine Bible in anticipation of her visit Saturday, May 4th, where she’ll teach her hugely popular class What Makes Great Wine Great?

Continue Reading

Glancy Wine Education Scholars
Glancy Wine Education Fund Scholars—Where are They Now?

Continue Reading